Thursday Boots vs Taft Boots: Brand Showdown

The decision to purchase luxury boots should never be taken lightly. With two promising brands like these, you simply have to pit them against each other and see what happens. Only one brand will emerge victorious in this comparison between Thursday Boots and Taft Boots, so let’s see who deserves the title.

Thursday Boot Company designs handmade boots, shoes, and accessories for men and women. The company places great emphasis on fair prices and reliability. Its products are a mix of durable work boots and elegant fashion boots. Thursday Boots wants its customers to feel confident and strong, no matter what the day has in store for them.

Taft specializes in high-quality boots, shoes, and sneakers for men. The concept for Taft was born out of a married couple’s search for the best shoes in the world. This couple built an empire out of their shared love of shoes, which continues to this day. Taft offers its customers the best possible prices and prides itself on its boots with intricate designs and patterns.

Regardless of the season, we all want reliable boots that can withstand all weather conditions—and when we’re strutting around in these treasures, they simply have to be stylish. In this comparison between Thursday Boots and Taft Boots, we dive into the materials, features, and aesthetics of each brand, focusing on the men’s collections.

Thursday Wingtip vs Taft Saint 

Thursday’s wingtip boots are made from handmade full-grain leather and feature an attractive brogue pattern. The Goodyear welt construction makes these boots durable but also slightly stiffer, and the rubber outsole with studs ensures good grip. The wingtips are fully lined with soft leather for maximum comfort. The cork midsole naturally adapts to your feet, so these boots become more and more a part of you the longer you wear them. Painful heels are a thing of the past: Thursday’s wingtips feature shock-absorbing insoles that make even the longest hikes pain-free. The wingtip boot is available in three colors: black and two shades of brown.

The Saint boot is Taft’s own interpretation of the wingtip style, featuring woven full-grain leather and broguing details. The Saint is fully lined with super-soft calfskin leather. The Blake stitching construction gives it durability and flexibility. A multi-layer leather sole with rubber inserts provides additional traction. The Saint boot is vegetable-tanned and chrome-free, with leather that has been hand-painted and dyed. It’s almost like wearing a work of art. The Saint is available in four colors: black, brown tones, and a striking camouflage variant.

Winner: Thursday Boots

Choosing the Wingtip over the Saint was a tough decision. The Saint clearly has a more intricate design, and one extra color option, but appearances aren’t all that matter. The Wingtip has added features that the Saint lacks, like a shock-absorbing insole and foot-molding midsole.

Thursday Limited Edition Captain vs Taft Jack

Next, in our comparison between Thursday Boots and Taft Boots, we look at two competing models of lace-up boots featuring outer materials and leather caps and heels.

The Limited Edition Captain Boot is made of black, weatherproof suede and Italian leather. It has a retro look that could add some much-needed variety to your boot collection. As always with Thursday Boots, the Goodyear welt construction ensures high durability. The Limited Edition Captain molds perfectly to your feet thanks to its cork midsole. A highlight of these boots are their 18-karat gold-plated eyelets. So if you want to impress or spice up a casual look, this Captain is a great choice. The Captain Boot is available in three colors: Gold Brown, Bourbon, and Black.

The Jack boot from Taft is much less conspicuous and impresses with its understated style. The upper material of the Jack boot is made of full-grain calfskin and water-repellent wool, making it much more suitable for wet weather than the suede Captain boot. Although the suede of the Captain boot is weatherproof, this material is still more susceptible than wool. The Jack boot has a leather sole with rubber inserts for durability and comfort. The Blake stitching construction ensures durability and flexibility. The Taft boot is available in significantly more colors, namely in 12 shades ranging from light beige to black, as well as in camouflage.

Winner: Taft

The limited edition Captain boot is undoubtedly cool. I mean, it has gold laces, but again, looks aren’t everything in this comparison between Thursday Boots and Taft Boots. The Jack boot is available in many more color options and its look is more versatile compared to the Captain. The Jack boot goes with more outfits than the Captain because of its simplicity. Another important factor in this decision was the wool material of the Jack boot, which is better protected against the elements than suede.

Thursday Duke vs Taft Outback 

In this part of the comparison between Thursday Boots and Taft Boots, we will compare the timeless Chelsea boot models from both brands. For the purposes of comparison, we have selected two suede models.

The first thing you should know about the Duke is that its upper is made of weatherproof suede. This gives you a certain degree of security, as normal suede and bad weather do not mix well. The Goodyear welt construction is used here as well, as are the shock-absorbing insole and the rubber outsole with lugs. DuraEVA™ comfort strips are located on the sides of the Duke model. There is no further information about what material this is, and an internet search also yielded no results. It appears to be a stretchy fabric that, like the pull tab, makes the boots easier to put on and take off. The suede version of the Duke model is available in two colors: honey and olive.

Quality

A reliable pair of boots must be able to keep up with the pace and demands of everyday life. When choosing between premium brands such as Thursday Boots and Taft, it is important to understand how they are made and the level of thought and skill that goes into their designs.

Thursday Boots products are made from high-quality materials such as Italian and chrome-tanned leather and weatherproof suede. They feature a reliable Goodyear welt construction that is hand-stitched to provide extra strength, durability, and comfort for every wearer. The company works with experienced artisans from around the world, including Mexico, Portugal, Spain, and the United States, to ensure that all shoes are carefully handcrafted.

With some of the most beautiful shoes in Europe, Taft ensures that every boot is cut and sewn by hand by skilled artisans. Taft boots are designed for durability and are made with Blake stitch construction to enhance overall comfort, flexibility, and an elegant finish. Taft uses the finest leather, wool, and suede to create highly original designs. The shoes are carefully crafted like painted canvases and feature unique broguing patterns and color combinations.

Winner: Taft

Taft offers us high-quality, creative, and reliable boots. In terms of overall quality, they are the most promising—their efforts are evident in the hand-stitched details and the raw materials used. Furthermore, wool is not typically used in the manufacture of weatherproof boots. Taft has managed to impress its customers with materials that are both reliable and original. The fascinating patterns on the boots and the care with which they are made make Taft a deserving winner in this category.

Customer Ratings

For this comparison between Thursday Boots and Taft Boots, we collected customer reviews from both brands’ websites and their respective Facebook and Instagram accounts. Customers consistently commented on similar features for both brands, revealing common trends. Here is a summary of customer reviews for Thursday Boots and Taft:

There are many positive reviews for both brands, but naturally negative ratings as well. Here is a breakdown of some of the red flags associated with each brand:

Thursday Boots

• Their boots were scratched and damaged after one wear
• Customer service did not help with return/exchange issues
• Their sizing is not as accurate as indicated – one pair fits, but one pair is too large

Taft 

Their production needs to improve – their sales are affordable but sizes run out too quickly

Price & Value

Prices vary between Thursday Boots and Taft, but we will look at the products featured in this comparison between Thursday Boots and Taft Boots:

• Thursday’s Wingtip: $235
• Taft’s Saint Boot: $295
• Thursday Captain Boot: $349
• Taft’s Jack Boot: $250
• Thursday’s Duke Boot: $199

Winner: Thursday Boots

Overall, Taft’s prices are not as affordable as Thursday Boots. Admittedly, the hand stitching and painting on Taft boots naturally cost more. Both brands produce high-quality boots, so Thursday Boots products are more affordable but still reliable in terms of workmanship.

We Choose: Taft

In compiling this review of Thursday Boots and Taft Boots, we concluded that Taft shoes are the overall favorite among fans. Thursday Boots was a worthy competitor, but Taft truly impressed us in 5 out of 8 categories.

The quality of the shoes is crucial. Both brands claim to have the best boots, but with Taft, appearances are not deceiving. The care they put into designing their shoes is evident at first glance. The combination of high-quality craftsmanship and original aesthetics is a true art form. Although Taft products are more expensive than Thursday Boots, as a direct-to-consumer brand, they offer attractive special deals throughout the year.

We should always pay attention to customer feedback. When multiple customers have positive shopping experiences and keep coming back, we are more inclined to get to know their brand better. Taft has a reputation for excellence in customer service. The brand values customer feedback, and the customers themselves inspire Taft to perform at their best.

Both brands sell beautifully designed boots, but in this comparison between Thursday Boots and Taft Boots, what ultimately mattered was what it takes to satisfy their customers. Taft has proven itself to be a trustworthy brand that you can rely on. Congratulations to Taft!

For a deeper insight into these brands, read our full reviews of Thursday Boots and Taft Shoes.